Opening remarks by Executive Vice-President Teresa Ribera on the Commission decision to approve UniCredit's acquisition of Commerzbank

Thank you. Thank you so much and thanks for being here.

It's a relevant merger decision that we have taken today. We have approved the acquisition of Commerzbank by UniCredit, which is probably the biggest cross-border banking deal we have had since the financial crisis, bringing together Italy's and Germany's second-largest banks.

This is part of a much bigger effort to build an integrated banking system that better serves European citizens and businesses, and one that is ready for the challenges ahead. An economy that works, a single market that is not fragmented, and financial services and banking services that are available all across Europe.

We have made progress over the years, but our banking sectors remain largely national still. We have 27 national markets with different views, different players, and still barriers. And we may wonder why this is the case, and the answer we get is that there may be many different reasons.

Capital and liquidity can't move freely within banks that operate across borders. There are different national rules, different supervisory practices, and in some cases political preferences for keeping banks domestically owned, which means lots of things for businesses and for citizens.

A German bank may not give a loan to an SME unless their headquarters are in Germany. An Italian bank will only offer a mortgage for a couple buying their home if the house is located in Italy. Many people and businesses like to know that they can visit their bank's branch in person when they need to.

 And from the perspective of banks, since retail or consumer banking is local, they say they are often not big enough to ensure cost savings or economies of scale to justify expanding cross-border. So, banks often find it easier to stay national than to operate as a single pan-European bank.

But we have many examples of businesses with operations across Europe that operate in national and local markets that could enjoy having this single market.

We may think of German and French supermarket chains in nearly every large town in Europe, Spanish clothing chains on high streets in most European cities, and European telecom operators providing connectivity to citizens in several member states.

This continued fragmentation in the banking sector comes at a big cost for our citizens, businesses, and competitiveness. And it is true that we are slowly starting to see local branches of Europe's biggest banks in big cities throughout the European Union. The main leadership in this field comes from Commissioner Albuquerque; we know that one of the reasons why costs remain high is that we still do not have a true single market in this field.

Enrico Letta and Mario Draghi have stated that Europe cannot afford the cost of fragmentation and that we must complete the savings and investments union. Some estimates show that removing constraints on the liquidity held in cross-border subsidiaries of EU banks could release around 230 billion euros.

As I say, this is the main task of Commissioner Albuquerque to deepen the single market and advance the banking union, and this is quite an important effort. We need a more integrated financial sector capable of financing our businesses and supporting our competitiveness while preserving financial stability and customers' choice. This is not the first attempt to bring together banks from different member states, but in this case, we see to what extent, when enforcing competition tools, we can help in this effort. This case shows that large cross-border mergers are possible in this sector.

They can happen when the right conditions are in place and when the rules are applied carefully and rigorously. Today's unconditional approval of UniCredit's acquisition of Commerzbank is a good example of the kind of cross-border merger that can deliver positive scaling up of EU banks, improve their efficiency, and help them better compete internationally.

This operation is fully in line with the positive approach to scaling up that we are setting out in our merger guidelines to be adopted before the end of the year. UniCredit and Commerzbank are important European banking groups and are largely complementary. UniCredit is already present in Germany with millions of customers, while Commerzbank serves over 11 million individuals and business customers in Germany. Our investigation focused on whether this deal could leave businesses in Germany with fewer options for their banking needs if they choose to no longer bank with UniCredit or Commerzbank.

And the conclusion was that no, there is nothing that shows that this could be the case. Businesses including SMEs could still have enough alternative banks for the services they need, including German commercial banks and cooperative banks, as well as international banks that already operate in Germany. Of course, this decision is not a green light for every single merger in the banking sector. We will always look at every operation case by case. But it shows we support companies increasing in scale when this does not create competition concerns. In fact, in the past years, the Commission has approved a number of cross-border banking mergers. We want a more integrated European banking market, we want stronger European banks, and we want to achieve this while safeguarding competition and protecting consumers. I really hope that today's decision will help encourage the emergence of truly integrated cross-border EU banking groups, aligning our efforts with those led by Commissioner Albuquerque.

Thank you so much.

Zie je content die volgens jou niet op deze site hoort? Check onze disclaimer.